Baby food

I am spending a lot of time these days thinking about baby food, or, rather, what to feed a baby. Brigid is not that fond of eating solid food, continuing her protest that this stuff I keep shoveling into her does not properly feel like eating.

Though I usually prefer to make my own baby food, both in Beijing and in the US I have had to look at buying commercially available food. Of course there are differences between the products marketed in China and those in the U.S. I wonder at what these differences mean to how we raise our children. What do the first foods we introduce to a baby signify about our expectations for that baby? Like what we hope to gain from toys, what do we think baby food does for our babies, exactly?

Here are images of a Chinese baby food aisle at a mid-size grocery store (not Wal-Mart). Some food in jars, but many, many, boxes of powdered cereal, rice, and noodles with some flavoring mixed in. This, of course, doesn't include the whole other aisle of powdered milk and formula products.




In the US, the ratio seems reversed. A small selection of boxed cereals and so many choices of food in jars.


Of course, this is only commercially available food. What families prepare on their own wouldn't be included. But it is interesting to me to see these differences in the grocery stores.

Even in the US, we see differing opinions on what baby food is meant to do. Some people believe in an early introduction of cereal to promote longer night-time sleeping for baby and parents. Some believe in postponing all solids until the second half of the baby's first year as the ecological breastfeeding component of NFP. Even the order in which to introduce certain foods is something that we see differing opinions in the West.

I'm interested in learning more about what the current popular theories are in China about what babies eat and when. One of Randy's employees has a baby close to Brigid's age. I ran into on the street one day, around the time both babies were four months old. She was just returning from the store with a box of rice cereal in her hand. She told me it was time that we fed our babies rice cereal and then was surprised that I was still planning to wait a little longer. I didn't see any signs of readiness in Brigid (and, heck, if maybe I still don't). She had mentioned it to Randy, too, and found his response about solid foods and process of introduction odd. Interesting, too, that her baby's primary care-giver, the mother-in-law, was pushing for delaying solid food for the baby.

It seems at times some of our popular theories about child rearing are about fifty years out of sync with one another. In China, formula is popular, as well as rice cereal at an early age. In the U.S. more and more mothers are interested in extended breast-feeding and delaying solid foods. These are attitudes wrapped up in industrialisation, pediatric theory, and economic development, among a host of other cultural factors (you can't ignore the working mother angle, for instance). As long as I am not getting yelled at by random Chinese women about my perceived negligence as a parent, I find these differences endlessly fascinating.

Comments

CaliValleyGirl said…
I have a Chinese au-pair, and it has been very interesting discussing the differences. It was almost a struggle at first with feeding, but now she defers to my wishes...but I do think they are very much more about "efficiency" and speeding up the whole eating process, meaning how quickly they start eating certain foods.

Oh, and the whole early potty training thing is interesting too...apparently she got here too late to potty train my son in time, but she did bring the split butt pants, which I told her would be okay for him to wear around the house, but wouldn't be considered socially acceptable outside the house...kids can't just squat at the playground here...lols...

But it has been fun.
Jen Ambrose said…
A lot of my American friends in china that have nannies/ayis have that same problem once their kids reach the age of self-feeding. It is considered an act of love in China to feed children; we Americans stress the growing independence. I can't count how many times when Myles was two-and-a-half to three-years-old that chinese people would express surprise that he could feed himself.
Whimsy said…
I just offer my babies food, manually pre-mushed, from the table. My children turned their noses to it until their teeth erupted.

I have five children and have never bought baby food. I'm too lazy to make it, either.

My children have always enjoyed good health and have never had digestive issues.

God is Good!