Dumb Plan B questions

These are rattling around in my head.

Is Plan B only allowed to be sold to women, not to men?

How are the pharmacists to assure that the Plan B pills are consumed by the purchaser? Should they have to take them onsite?

I guess I watch too many shows like Desperate Housewives and can imagine a myriad of sinister possibilities.

Comments

John Lowell said…
Although a few days old, here are some related thoughts, Ambrose:

http://johnlowellblog.blogspot.com/

John Lowell
Anonymous said…
Actually, one of the articles I read (probably in the Wall Street Journal, so no link) mentioned men picking up the Plan B OTC... and I was thinking... excuse me? Great - so the 15-year-old girls with 19-year-old lovers can get Plan B. Way to go for keeping the kids safe!
Anonymous said…
It may be that the price will make girls think twice but to be able to purchase high concentrations of hormones -which are NOT innocuous--when the lower level birth control pills require a prescriptions seems stupid. Here is one thing--this way the girls do not have to see a physician and with STDs running rampant, theirs might as well leading to a future sterility or cancer.

You cannot tell me that some mother who is 3 months pregnant or something will not try to take this to abort! And what happens then?

It further encourages promiscuity. For a feminist to think this is some sort of freedom is twisted. This license is demeaning and women have never been so used and disrespected as they are now. And motherhood is also disrespected by men and women alike in many cases.

Make no mistake, this is another battle won by evil.
Anonymous said…
Can't confess to D-H TV habit, but the news from Austria re: "Dungeon Girl" certainly doesn't bode well. Consider those of a fundamentalist mentality such as husbands who demand their wives wear Burkas to hide their "shame" in public?

Pray that those of other faiths don't permit this means of 'subordination' (today's second reading) to be confused with what St. Paul encouraged wives to subject themselves to, wreaking havoc if abused for a life time.

And pray too that the first unwilling victim of Jen's hellish scenarios call the domestic violence hotline and prosecute the pants off the perps - perhaps inviting development of legislation along the lines of Connor'r Law, and a usher in a profound change in hearts and minds...

St Monica, grandmother of Gift God Adeotadus, pray for us!
Anonymous said…
Oops that should have read

'gift of God, Adeotadus'
Anonymous said…
There are lots of OTC drugs that, if used incorrectly, may cause harm. The government has to assume some level of intelligence on the part of users for both OTC and prescription drugs. Even then I find the government a bit patronizing; they allow antihistamines OTC at half the prescription strength assuming, apparently, that no one will just take two to get the equivalent strength of a prescription.

But clearly Plan B does no harm to the public at large. This is well established by years of prescription use in the US and years of OTC use in other countries.

And ethically, Plan B also does no harm. The action of Plan B causes an embryo to be expelled. Research indicates that about 50% of all naturally occuring embyros are routinely expelled. So thousands, THOUSANDS, of five-ten-twenty cell embyros are dumped by nature every day. If every embyro was such a valuable, protect-at-all-cost item, nature surely would have done a better job of managing them. Clearly, in nature embyros are very expendable. Using Plan B simply re-creates conditions for that to happen by choice rather than by chance.

From another perspective, if you think/believe that god=nature, then there are thousands of god-approved abortions every day, since every embyro that nature dumps could be another person.

Cheers!

Ray
Anonymous said…
Ray,

You've got to be kidding, right? Plan B does no harm to the public at large? Where do I begin?

How about giving men and women more reason to be sexually irresponsible? What about older men who will use this drug as a means to exploit young girls? How about making God's gift of sexuality cheap and demeaning? Plan B makes sex appear to be consequence free even though it is not. Of course, contraception and abortion have already had this impact on people's attitudes towards sex which is why we have so much pornography, STDs, sexual assault, etc.

Your excuse that nature (God) expels embryos so it's OK to use Plan B does not make sense. Lots of people die naturally every day too. Does that mean it's OK to commit suicide, murder, euthanasia? Lots of people get cancer. Should people intentionally do things to cause cancer? Just because God allows some embryos to be expelled doesn't mean it's alright for someone to intentionally expel an embryo. Maybe those embryos were expelled because they were so severely deformed that they did not survive. On the other hand, a woman taking Plan B could abort an embryo that is perfectly healthy and would have survived on its own. Anyway, life begins at conception. An embryo is a tiny, living human being. We have no right to cause harm to it.

Lisa
Anonymous said…
Ray,

You said: "The government has to assume some level of intelligence on the part of users for both OTC and prescription drugs."

That's very funny considering that Plan B was designed for people who are too unintelligent and irresponsible to use birth control before having sex.

Lisa
Anonymous said…
Jen...I'll let you know the "rules" about how to dispense Plan B when we get them...I suspect it will be similar to the signature log thing we do now for the OTC Sudafed purchases.

until then...just to clarify...Plan B is NOT the same as the RU pill...Plan B will NOT abort an already established fetus...it will only prepare the womb to NOT accept an embryo....